[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[HCDX] SW brasilian radio stations DXCPR - Clarification
would like to clarify some things:
In first place, to say that all is a great lie in this discussion.
The list that the Rocco corrected was a sweeping, all old fashioned and full
one of inaccuracies.
Desire that you know that I let participate exactly in the DXCB, by the
incompetence of the directive cupola, mainly of Mr. Rocco that published a
list that updated every 3 years. Towards long time I insisted so that the
list was updated but assiduously and never they took care of my request.
proposed a new project for the DXCB in mayo/2007 (this list that we are
using was the one that we sent to them) and did not accept, mainly Mr. Rocco
that was scared to lose the paternity of the list. I proposed to them then,
to work together and they did not accept either. It was there that I
separated completely of group DXCB and we created the DXCPR
www.dxclube.com.br and a new list, in new format and updated day to day.
After all, that is the reason of a list, to maintain updated information.
Therefore, an update every 3 years does not have sense.
In the DXCPR we have some collaborators who send the information to us of
several regions of all the country, but the greater work I do, spending
money in telephone calls for the transmitters, consulting with the people in
charge of the transmitters in all Brazil. I like much to do this; I am a
lover of the OM.
We have a list with many members and about 300 posts per month
http://br.groups.yahoo.com/group/dxclube/
It is enough with crossing posts, to verify the hundreds of updates that I
already did, sending the list for different forums anywhere in the world.
Clear that this it is an enormous country, of continental dimensions and
always it will be possible to find some error in the list.
I recently download a copy of the list published by DXCB and I noticed that
now he is exactly equal to my list with minimum errors to my favor. They are
taking advantage of the spreading my updates and simply, correcting the list
of them. Simply ridiculous.
I only know that they are dying of jealousy, by the good repercussion that
we are having. The list that we published is reliable, and it is already
reference anywhere in the world, thanks to serious and responsible a work
that we do here.
I also say to them that the DXCPR is not a club of a man only, the
difference is in which here single we have voluntary collaborators and we
did not receive anything to participate, is a work in favor of the DX and
nothing else, then, a mini foundation in that accusation of plagiarism does
not exist. One is the continuity of a work that badly was directed and that
is a serious defect of the DXCB, if you enter there with new ideas, they do
not admit it, it is necessary to be in everything in agreement with them.
It was by that reason that I moved away of them, to be able to make a work
of quality
73
MARCELO VILELA BEDENE
CURITIBA-PR-BRASIL
PX5G6444 (Off-Road)
marcelo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
mbdn@xxxxxxxxxx
DX CLUBE DO PARANÁ (DXCPR)
http://www.dxclube.com.br
MSN: mbdn3000@xxxxxxxxxxx
SKYPE:mbedene4404
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mbedene/sets/
----- Original Message -----
From: "Willi Passmann" <>
To: "Rocco Cotroneo" <>
Cc: "HCDX" <>
Sent: Thursday, June 05, 2008 8:53 AM
Subject: Re: [HCDX] New Perseus Databases
> Hi Rocco,
>
> thanks for your mail which gave new information to me. However, I think
> this is a matter that should be discussed between you and Marcelo Bedene.
> I do not claim any rights regarding the content of the lists collected in
> the Perseus Databases. I see my task in combining frequency lists (of
> course with permission of the publisher), and to add functions like
> displaying sunrise / sunset times and distance, as well as receiver
> operation for the Perseus.
>
> As I did not know any background of the DXCB - DXCP issue until now, I do
> not feel well prepared for any final judgement. When I downloaded your
> list some minutes ago (Link 1 gives a 404-error, btw) I noticed that the
> list is from 2007 and does not contain any coordinates which are essential
> for the above mentioned calculations.
> But I offer to add your list to the Perseus Databases. Just send an Excel
> file to me and much more DXers will be able to take notice of your work.
> Let them decide what list they prefer.
> What do you think?
>
> vy 73
> Willi
>
>
> Rocco Cotroneo schrieb:
>>
>>
>> On Wed, Jun 4, 2008 at 10:33 AM, Willi Passmann >> wrote:
>>
>> Hello all,
>>
>> a new version of the Perseus databases is available at
>> http://www.4shared.com/dir/5567845/166a39bd/sharing.html
>>
>> Willi
>> just to inform you that Bedene's list (DXCP is a sort of one-man club)
>> is basically a Excel copy of the Brazilian Medium Wave list which has
>> been edited for years by the Dx Clube do Brasil, with a few more bells
>> and whistles.
>> Our list - used and acknowledged by hundreds of Mw dxers around the
>> world - is now at its Fourth edition.
>> http://www.ondascurtas.com/listasemissorasmw.asp
>>
>> I understand that Bedene's list is suitable for your software purpose. I
>> just wanted to let you know how his work has been done without giving any
>> credit to probably over 90 per cent of his entries, and dozens of our
>> collaborators in the past eight years.
>>
>> Rocco Cotroneo
>> Dx Clube do Brasil
---[Start Commercial]---------------------
Order your WRTH 2008:
http://www.hard-core-dx.com/redirect2.php?id=wrth2008
---[End Commercial]-----------------------
________________________________________
Hard-Core-DX mailing list
Hard-Core-DX@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://montreal.kotalampi.com/mailman/listinfo/hard-core-dx
http://www.hard-core-dx.com/
_______________________________________________
THE INFORMATION IN THIS ARTICLE IS FREE. It may be copied, distributed
and/or modified under the conditions set down in the Design Science License
published by Michael Stutz at
http://www.gnu.org/licenses/dsl.html